The Best 4 Slice Toaster On Your Counter Reviewed and Rated in 2025

Below are our reviews on the nine top-rated toasters on the market.

1. Cuisinart CPT-180P1 Metal Classic

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Made of long-lasting stainless steel
• Wide slots
• Solid construction 
• Easy-to-use dials
• Multiple toasting functions

Cons:

• Not toast evenly

2. Elite Gourmet ECT-3100 Long Slot

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Toasts bagels evenly
• Offer smart sensor 
• Affordable price
• Have flip-up grille rack

Cons:

• Easily get hot

3. BELLA 4 Slice Toaster

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Stylish design
• 1800 watt toasting system
• Precise shade settings control
• Removable crumb tray
• Anti-jam 

Cons:

• Shallow slots

4. BLACK+DECKER T4569B 4-Slice Toaster

View on Amazon

Pros:

• User friendly operation
• Have cancel option
• Simple lifting mechanism
• 7-level color selections

Cons:

• A bit slow

5. Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Wide temperature range
• Comes with many useful features
• Six browning settings
• Low roasting time

Cons:

• Metal edges can get hot

6. Elite Gourmet ECT-4829 Long Slot

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Produce thick baked goods
• Defrost setting 
• Even browning
• LED countdown timer
• Adjustable slots

Cons:

• The knob are hard to see

7. GE Stainless Steel Toaster 4 Slice

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Automatic shutoff function
• Extra-wide slots
• Sleek stainless steel finish
• Have 2 sets of high-lift levers
• Seven accurate shade settings

Cons:

• Short slots

8. Cuisinart CPT-142P1

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Compact and lightweight 
• Reheat and defrost setting
• Unique bagel toasting function
• Dual toasting control

Cons:

• Sometimes it gives uneven toasting

9. Whall Stainless Steel Toaster

View on Amazon

Pros:

• High-quality stainless steel
• Easy to maintain
• Strong springs
• Coil design bottom
• Six gear adjustments

Cons:

• Highest setting burns bread black

Even though a toaster is a rather straightforward device, there are still a lot of things to consider. Here is a quick list of factors to take into account while focusing your search:

Design

Most of today's toasters are designed with visual appeal because open-plan living is prevalent in many homes.

Everything from a toaster with a classic design to a chic steel one is available for purchase.

Popular models sometimes have patterns or textures, but be aware that they might be more difficult to maintain clean than polished metal surfaces.

Features

Although some models also have settings for defrosting, warming, and browning, the typical number of shade options is seven. 

Shade selections don't always indicate how long the toaster will operate before popping, though they sometimes do. 

They typically tell you where your bread will end on a spectrum of brownness. Options increase in number as the scale widens.

Besides, you can look for models with a "keep warm" mode. When toasting is complete, this mode will keep the toast warm till you're ready for it.

For those who do not know exactly your taste after popping, a function with a name like "a little more" or "a little longer" can be a nice addition.

Slot Size

If you frequently toast bagels or homemade bread, get a toaster with 1.5 inches wide or wider slots.

Most four-slot toasters have big slots for one specific piece of bread apiece. 

But some models include two continuous long slots that can accommodate either two slices of bread or one piece that is very lengthy or irregular in shape.

Crumb Tray

Toasters now frequently include a crumb tray typically hidden in the base. 

It should be simple to slide out and replace after emptying, and it shouldn't have crevices where crumbs can collect over time and impair the toaster's performance.

1. Should I clean a new toaster before using it?

Cleaning new cooking utensils before using them is always a great idea. Cooking a few slices of bread and throwing them away is a smart alternative because the first couple of pieces of toast can pick up that new toaster flavor.

2. Is it possible to repair a broken toaster?

Depending on the extent of the issue, you might be able to fix your toaster. 

Inconsistent performance and broken pop-up features are two of the most frequent problems, which can be easily fixed without tinkering with the electrics. 

However, if the issue involves a defective heating element or a total equipment breakdown, you should let a trained expert handle the repairs.

3. How long should a toaster last? 

The lifespan of a normal toaster is about five to eight years. By regularly clearing off crumbs, refraining from sticking pointed metal pieces inside the slots, and cooking frozen foods less frequently, you can extend the life of your toaster.

4. Is a toaster with more power better?

It toasts more quickly the greater the wattage. A toaster with low wattage may result in toasts that are chewy outside yet fluffy inside. 1800W or higher is a good power output for a four-slice toaster.

5. Do toasters use a lot of electricity?

The typical range for the electricity consumption of 4-slice toasters is between 1400W and 2300W. 

Meanwhile, the 2-slice toasters have an 850W power rating, and models with wide slots and "high-power" settings can use up to 300W more electricity. 

Elite Gourmet ECT-4829 Long Slot was simply an outstanding all-around player for best 4 slice toaster overall for its aesthetically pleasing and practical. 

BELLA 4 Slice Toaster is a great choice for adding a touch of retro elegance, and we adored the straightforward.

Finally, Cuisinart CPT-142P1 won our hearts as it impressed us with how simple it is to remove the bread.