Best Old-fashioned Ice Cream Maker: Ice Lovers Recommend

1. Nostalgia Old Fashioned Ice Cream Machine

View on Amazon

Pros

• Attractive price
• Four-quart capacity
• Lightweight and portable
• Easy to use

Cons

• Quite poor material
• Much time require

2. Elite Gourmet EIM402 Ice Cream Maker

View on Amazon

Pros

• Large output per batch
• Low-sound operation
• Affordable
• Easy to use

Cons

• Take much time

3. Elite Gourmet EIM916 Old Fashioned Machine

View on Amazon

Pros

• Six-quart capacity
• Safe and quiet operation
• Long warranty period
• Easy to clean

Cons

• Hand crank issues

4. Elite Gourmet EIM916 Vintage Ice Cream Maker

View on Amazon

Pros

• Easy to use
• Quiet operation
• Quick ice-making
• Large capacity

Cons

• Bucket problems
• No clear instruction

5. Ninja NC301 CREAMi Ice Cream Maker

View on Amazon

Pros

• Compact yet fashion design
• Mix-ins function
• Versatility
• Innovative creameries system

Cons

• High Price
• Slower than expected

The list below includes some essential criteria you may want to consider before purchasing. 

Price

Old-fashioned ice cream makers cost less than modern ones. The price varies widely, ranging from $40 to $200 based on its brands, quality, and unique feature.  

Capacity

Old-fashioned ice cream maker typically has a small, compact, and portable design. If you’re a travel enthusiast, it’ll be very convenient. 

However, remember to check the capacity of your product to make sure it can perform well and make enough ice per batch to serve your needs.  

Ease of use

Despite some exceptions, most old-fashioned ice cream makers are run by manual force, which means you have to use your hand to operate them. Hence, pay attention to choosing a model you find comfortable using.

Ease of clean

There are some kinds of designs that have very tiny and unremovable components. Over time, these places will be the ideal environment for mold and bacteria to reproduce and develop. Consider this factor when shopping. 

Warranty

This factor shows how confident and responsible the manufacturers are. The standard warranty period of an old-fashioned ice cream maker is six months to two years. 

How does an old-fashioned ice cream maker work?

The operation principle of a vintage ice cream maker is straightforward.

An ice maker consists of a metal canister buried in a combination of ice and rock salt. The surrounding ice bath chills the canister. 

Then, it freezes ice cream from the cold edges by the paddle inside, replacing the colder ice cream with warmer ice cream. It churns the mixture again and again until done. 

How long does an old-fashioned ice cream maker take?

It typically takes 30 to 45 minutes for an ice cream maker to freeze a batch. But as you can see, if you decide to use a hand-crank ice cream maker, you'll have to work out quite hard!

How full should I fill an ice cream maker?

The amount will vary by model but remember not to overfill your ice cream maker. It needs extra room to churn ice cream and incorporate air into the finished product when freezing. 

Do the old-fashioned ice maker run by electricity?

The old-fashioned ice, also called salt and ice, is the traditional style and doesn't need electricity in most cases. However, like it or not, it requires manual labor. But some, especially children, are really into this experience. 

How much salt does it take to make ice cream?

When filling the tub with ice, you can use rock salt or table salt. About ¼ -½ cups of salt is okay.

The ice will melt over time, and you can continue to add more ice and salt. Also, you can choose to layer ice and rock salt to speed up the freezing process.

Now it’s time for you to make your decision. Are you ready to be on the way to getting the best old-fashioned ice cream maker? 

In case you still feel confused, our top pick is Ninja Ice Cream Maker. We can say for sure that it’ll satisfy your demand.

Hopefully, with our tips and tricks supplied, you can have the product that fits all your needs. 

Don’t forget to leave a comment below. We’re looking forward to hearing about your final pick.

Thank you for reading!