Best Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven in 2025

Now let's take a look at the best Hamilton toaster oven on this list!

1. Hamilton Beach Air Fryer Countertop 31523

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Roll-top door for convenience
• Large cooking space
• Four cooking functions
• Gets hot quick
• Toasts pretty evenly

Cons:

• Exterior is hot for long time

2. Hamilton Beach Air Fryer Countertop Toaster Oven

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Anti-skid feet on wet surfaces
• Has a retro design
• Stay- cool exterior surface
• Extra-wide toast slot
• Separate toast shade selector

Cons:

• A weird clicking noise

3. Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven 31401

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Appealing price point
•  Broiling, baking, and toasting options
• Comes with bake pan
• Stainless steel exterior
• 30-minute timer

Cons:

• Short power cord

4. Hamilton Beach 4-Slice 31143

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Easy to operate
• Stay-on setting
• Detachable crumb tray
• Auto shut off mode

Cons:

• Limited timer

5. Hamilton Beach 6-Slice Countertop Toaster Oven 31127D

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Perfect cooking capacity
• Ergonomic design
• Durable build quality
• Removable crumb tray
• Comfortable curved knobs

Cons: 

• Not for large families

6. Hamilton Beach Sure-Crisp Air Fryer 31403

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Metal basket included
• Excellent toasting performance
• Patented controls
• Elegant stainless steel exterior
• Fast cooking with 1500 watts

Cons:

• Difficult to turn off

7. Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven 31123D

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Efficient
• Easy cleanup
• Sleek design
• Toast quickly

Cons:

• Not for large pizzas

8. Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 4-Slice Oven 31344DA

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Compact size for easy store
• Easy access to the food
• Easy-to-use knob
• Ready bell

Cons:

• Release smoke while operating

9. Hamilton Beach 31190C

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Nice digital control
• Two hour timer 
• Six cooking settings
• Spacious interior

Cons:

• Did not come with a manual

10. Hamilton Beach 31107D

View on Amazon

Pros:

• Bake & broil settings
• Removable drip tray
• Steady cooking temps
• Ease of operation

Cons:

• The knobs are hard to read

As a consumer, you are aware that not each product is great. Determining whether or not to purchase a Hamilton Beach toaster oven can be challenging.

You can choose the best one for your needs with this shopping guide.

Capacity

Compared to the slotted toasters, Hamilton Beach toaster ovens often occupy more countertop space, but they are still regarded as space-saving equipment. 

If countertop space is at a premium, you can think about a roll-top door style. A 9- to 12-inch pizza, a frozen entrée, or even several bread slices can typically fit within.

Control

Simple controls for entry-level toaster ovens could include a spring-powered timer, a mode choice for cooking, and an adjustable thermometer.

Modern models use a digital touchscreen and display in place of the analog timer. To avoid overcooking, some also offer an automatic shut-off feature.

Functionality

A toaster oven is a clear improvement over a conventional slotted toaster for many users. Every Hamilton Beach toaster oven enables customers to toast slices of bread to their desired level of crispiness.

Additionally, several versions have a baking feature that uses heaters below and above the meal. Broiling, which uses a top element to produce high heat, is the third most frequent use. 

Some mid-range to high-end versions have convection fans, and a few are equipped with air fryer functions.

Material

You should also consider the material of your new oven. Finding something that will meet your demands is vital because not all products are constructed of the same materials. 

Before determining which material is suitable for you, browse the manufacturer's brochures because they may provide various materials.

1. Are there any convection cooking options available on Hamilton Beach toaster ovens?

Yes, you can. But make sure it doesn't touch any of the heated elements. Also, don't cover the crumb tray.

2. Can I put foil in a Hamilton Beach toaster oven?

Yes, you can. But make sure it doesn't touch any of the heated elements. Also, don't use it for crumb tray cover.

3. Is Hamilton Beach a good brand name?

Hamilton Beach showcases premium names that rank among the best-selling products in their industries. Around 81% of all HBB's revenues and 99.1% of all profits come from Hamilton Beach (FY2016).

4. How do I toast a bagel in a Hamilton Beach toaster oven?

With the insides facing up, put your cut bagel on the bottom or center rack. While your oven is on broil, shut the door. To toast and golden-brown the tops, broil for 2 to 4 minutes.

5. Is it safe to leave the toaster oven plugged in?

Toasters are made to produce a lot of heat, which is required to brown bread. Therefore, a toaster oven that is in use could catch fire. 

So, we go through everything you need to know before buying a toaster, and we include some of the best Hamilton ovens. 

Our first choice for the best Hamilton beach toaster oven is the Hamilton Beach 2-in-1 Countertop Oven 31156, Hamilton Beach 4-Slice 31143, and Hamilton Beach Easy Reach 31344DA, which offer the best value for your money.